Britain, Government, Health, NHS, Politics

The abolition of NHS England

HEALTH

Intro: The Labour Government’s shake-up of the NHS in England aims to cut waste and shift resources, but the looming funding gap raises doubts about its impact

THE UK Government’s decision to abolish NHS England – the world’s largest quango – was cast as a bold strike against bureaucracy. The move is designed to cut waste, “shift money to the frontline”, and by placing the NHS in England under direct democratic control. It is a declaration of intent from Sir Keir Starmer who wants Labour not to be the party of bigger government but the party of smarter government. That’s the theory, at least. The reality, as with most things in government, is more complicated.

The announcement happens to be less of a grand health reform and more a strategic positioning exercise. Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, and the architect of this plan, is engaged in a delicate balancing act: convincing the Treasury that the NHS can stay within budget, while simultaneously lobbying for more money that he knows the health service will inevitably require. The cull of NHS England is a useful and headline-grabbing moment. It is one that will allow Mr Streeting to claim that he is shifting cash from managers to patient care, a necessary concession when preparing to argue for more Treasury investment.

The problem is that the numbers don’t add up. The savings from axing NHS England will be modest. The organisation’s cost to the Treasury is £2bn, a tiny fraction of the NHS’s £183bn budget for 2025/26. Of this, about £400m is spent on staff who work directly with local NHS bodies, and these roles will probably continue in some form. The savings come nowhere near enough to fill next year’s estimated £6.6bn funding gap. At best, it frees up a few hundred million pounds. At worst, it shifts costs elsewhere while causing months of upheaval in an already overstretched system.

The NHS faces mounting pressure to cut costs, with the Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, insisting that it must live within its means. Hospital trusts will need to tighten their belts even further. It does not take a health economist to recognise that when resources are cut, patient demand does not magically disappear – it simply resurfaces elsewhere. If community services shut-down to balance the books, then the pressure on GPs and A&E departments will only intensify. If the health service is told to do more with less, the risk is that it simply ends up doing less with less.

Sir Keir’s embrace of Mr Streeting’s reform agenda is a calculated gamble. The PM is backing an NHS overhaul that may not deliver as promised. His endorsement, however, bolsters Mr Streeting’s standing with the Treasury, which faces a looming fiscal shortfall. With tax rises off the table, and Ms Reeves’ fiscal straitjacket firmly in place, spending cuts after 2025/26 seem an inevitability.

The NHS may have won big in the last budget, but as the Darzi report warned, it remains in “serious trouble”. Years of under-investment and overcrowded hospitals, with no relief from an overstretched social care system, have left it desperately struggling. Without greater funding, it cannot meet the rising demand of an ageing population, let alone expand its workforce. The Health Secretary must keep pressing the Treasury for the resources he needs, cloaking each plea for cash in the fashionable language of “modernising reform”.

Such rhetorical agility is a skill that Westminster normally rewards. Consider, for example, how Universal Credit came into being. But whether he delivers on his three big shifts – moving care out of hospitals, prioritising prevention, and digitising the NHS – remains to be seen. If the health service deteriorates further, the government will soon find that it has not only failed to fix the NHS in England but has taken ownership of its decline.

Standard
Health, Medical, Science

Menopause misery. HRT isn’t the only answer

HEALTH

DR MAX PEMBERTON, an NHS psychiatrist and medical doctor, wrote recently on the significant shift in many doctors’ attitude towards Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT). For far too many years, peri- and post-menopausal women have to had to fight hard for their right to access this medication.

An increasing number of doctors are now open to the idea that prescribing HRT can have real benefits for their patients – and, undoubtedly, this has made a life-changing difference for many women. Even though some 13million women in the UK are going through the menopause, it is estimated that one in four have to visit their GP at least three times before getting appropriate treatment.

Last year, official draft guidelines were issued to GPs which said alternative treatments should be considered. These included talking therapies “alongside or as an alternative to” HRT to help reduce menopause symptoms such as insomnia, low mood, and hot flushes. These guidelines have now been revised with health officials backtracking after accusations of “medical misogyny” – the implication being that menopausal symptoms were “all in the mind”. The guidance issued by NICE now advises that HRT should be offered as the first line of treatment. Some may believe this a positive development, but Dr Pemberton is unsure.

The medic is known to be a keen fan of HRT and he has seen many patients’ lives transformed by it. But he goes on to say that HRT isn’t suitable for everyone and that talking therapies can help those women presenting with symptoms that have a psychological component.

Dr Pemberton says that many women talk about no longer feeling like themselves, a disconcerting sense of something having changed, a vague undercurrent of unease, despair, and discombobulation. Trying to address what causes this turmoil is far more complicated than simply a blip in hormone levels. And neither can it be explained away by a woman’s dissatisfaction with life and her sense of loss and malaise as a chemical reaction.

That’s not to say that hormones don’t play an important part. Medical professionals know that fluctuations in hormones can be responsible for low and poor mood.

Over the years, Dr Pemberton has seen far too many women struggling to cope and for whom HRT has been hugely beneficial – helping them, for instance, to manage anxiety caused by the menopause.

But the medic also believes there are other factors that contribute to a woman’s sense of losing herself. He points out that low mood and anxiety are a result of complex social and psychological factors, rather than simple biology.

Changes to the body, disrupted sleep, hot flushes, and so on, he says, can make any woman feel out of control and depressed.

Dr Pemberton documents and records other issues he’s heard women talk about – for example, erratic mood swings and out-of-character behaviour. There are stories of women having affairs, quitting their jobs, or leaving their husbands around the menopause.

While some would seek to blame this all on fluctuations in hormone levels, the evidence for this isn’t that compelling.

The clinician says it’s not at all clear that drops in oestrogen and progesterone, the female sex hormones that start to decline in menopause, are entirely responsible.

Rather, the medic believes that the menopause acts like a ticking clock. It suddenly makes women open their eyes and review their lives. Much of the trauma and emotional turmoil that besets many women as they navigate menopause isn’t the consequence of fluctuating hormones but of a re-evaluation of their life’ situation. For many, their sense of self and identity is closely bound up with their roles within their family, particularly those who are mothers, who may feel bereft at the prospect of an empty nest.

It is also a cruel aspect of the inequality between the sexes that women have to contend with a society that’s more judgmental about how woman age than men. For a lot of women in their 50s and 60s, they have given the best years of their lives to other people and their careers, and now they’re not sure why. A vast number of menopausal women now feel invisible.

Dr Pemberton has had many menopausal and post-menopausal women attending his clinics and hearing the sad story that they no longer feel like a woman.

It is here, he says, that these people would surely benefit from having the time and space to explore and discuss their feelings and situation. That’s where talking therapies can play a vital role for many who have become desperately unhappy.

In the opinion of Dr Max Pemberton, the answer to many complex problems precipitated by the menopause aren’t always going to be found in HRT pills, patches, and gels.

Standard
Britain, Economic, Government, Health, Politics

Politically the NHS is non-negotiable. That has to change.

NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE

Intro: The philosophy and funding model for the NHS is not fit for the 21st century. To fix it, we first need to admit that the NHS is broken

THE centrepiece of the opening ceremony of the 2012 London Olympic Games was a celebration of the NHS. This was understandable: the host country was projecting a healthcare system that is uniquely British.  

In this case, however, a description of “unique” says something deeply worrying. For it is uniquely British only because no other country has ever sort to copy or replicate it. The world was watching that Olympic opening ceremony, but no other country looked at those medics dancing energetically around the beds of their smiling patients and concluded that this was an institution they wanted to introduce into their own countries.

It is surely reasonable to ask, why not? And what does that say about the NHS?

There is no doubt that much of the public adoration of the NHS is founded on fading folklore memory of pre-1948 Britain when millions of people suffered illness and premature death because they could not afford to pay for a doctor. That obscenity cast a long shadow, but it’s time to consign such memories to the archives of history.

Most other countries, after all, have very similar histories. Britain was not unique in its suffering from appalling health inequalities in the past, or in its strident attempts to seek a better, more equitable way of looking after the health needs of its post-war population. Other nations faced the same challenges, and they arrived at different solutions.

But in Britain there can be no solutions other than the one that Nye Bevan, the Welsh MP who served as health secretary in the post-war Labour government, came up with more than 75 years ago.

We may live in a world transformed, a globalised world of advanced technologies undreamed of in the past century, a world of instant communication, high-powered algorithms, and artificial intelligence, but when it comes to health policy, Nye’s unflinching word is the secular equivalent of holy writ set in tablet and stone.

And heretics who doubt his word by quickly casting to the wind any suggestion of fruitful reform are castigated as malign. But maybe, just maybe, not everything the NHS does, and the way certain things are done, are perfect. Perhaps there are alternative ways of funding it, and that there might be lessons to be learned from the way other modern democracies provide healthcare for their own citizens.

Such is the current state of debate – stifled at every opportunity – and, yet the NHS is arguably the most important institution in the country. Funding has never been unlimited; the system has been stretched to its limits in recent years, resources are inefficiently allocated, and the country is still expected to provide a healthcare system for everyone based on 1948 ideals.

The combined cost of health services in England and Scotland is nearly £200billion a year. Despite this, still one in seven Scots languish on waiting lists for treatment. Economists predict that the funding crisis is only going to get worse as our population ages.

Why shouldn’t we be addressing these issues in a full and frank public debate? It would, after all, be in the interests of hard-pressed taxpayers’ who fund in full NHS services and provision.  

But every time politicians even raise the possibility of doing things differently, they are shouted down, accused of wishing to “privatise” the NHS or – worse – introduce an American style service that only the wealthy can afford, leaving the vast majority of people in Britain at the mercy of exploitative private health insurance companies.

And so, the unsustainable status quo goes on, with our political parties too frightened to explain exactly how they will address the demographic time bomb that is looming.

There are only two politically acceptable “solutions” to what now seems like a permanent NHS crisis: more funding – and even more funding.

Our politicians need to be slightly braver by showing some courage, by being more imaginative, and less terrified of incurring a disapproving look from voters. They need to be honest about the challenge we all face.

They would concede that a funding and organisational model brought into being a matter of months after the defeat of the Nazis, might not necessarily be the right model for healthcare in the third decade of the 21st century.

Could it be that any constructive criticism of the NHS, or any new thinking about alternative ways of funding healthcare, are shouted down because the arguments for maintaining the status quo are too fragile to withstand robust scrutiny?

TWO

WHY, then, faced with criticism of the NHS, do its defenders seek falsely to claim that the only choice is between what we already have and the admittedly dreadful service that American citizens must tolerate?

Why not admit that there are plenty of other health services in the world – systems that use a variety of funding mechanisms? And that many of them have better health outcomes than in the UK? Is it seriously being suggested that Britain has nothing to learn from those other countries?

The facts do not come any clearer. Britain comes nowhere near the top of league tables when international comparisons for cancer and cardiovascular survival rates are compiled. We even fall behind the United States on many metrics.

In a country whose society has been so fractured by our public debate about Brexit, it is extraordinary that even the most ardent Remainers, those who insist that the EU is better, more progressive, more caring, more tolerant than the insular, old fashioned, short-termist Britain, will draw the line at healthcare. We should all be more European in every aspects of our lives, they say, except when it comes to healthcare.

Germany, for example, has a healthcare system funded by a combination of public funds and private insurance. Its health outcomes, including life expectancy, puts Britain to shame.

The country has a public health system, but it’s financed in a radically different way from the NHS. Around 86 per cent of Germans are enrolled in schemes run by not-for-profit insurance organisations known as sickness funds. They choose which fund they sign up to.

These are paid for by deductions from wages with employee and employer contributions. Some small out-of-pocket payments are required for hospital visits and medicines.

The healthcare system in Germany is also better staffed than it is in the UK, relative to the population. Analysis by the Nuffield Trust in 2019 concluded that the UK had around nine nurses per 1,000 people, while in Germany there were about 14. The disparity in bed numbers was wider too, with Germany’s eight beds per 1,000 more than three times the UK figure.

In France, the healthcare system is funded by social security contributions, central government funding, and partly by patients themselves, who have to pay a percentage of costs for medical treatment or prescription drugs. Like the UK, France provides healthcare to every resident regardless of age, income, or status. But life expectancy for French women is the second highest in the world.

The healthcare system in Italy, also provided through a mixed public-private system, is considered one of the finest in the world.

Worryingly, a recent report by the King’s Fund concluded that Britain’s life expectancy rates are among the lowest in Europe.

As local health surgeries struggle to cope with the aftermath of the Covid pandemic, the dreaded 8am rush to get a GP appointment has become the bane of most people in this country. And every winter heralds a new crisis of hospital bed shortages.

And still the NHS is plagued by industrial action by nurses and junior doctors, who feel they are unrewarded, and have become cynical about their working practices and conditions of employment.

THREE

ACCORDING to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the UK spends more on healthcare than comparable countries (about 11.3 per cent of GDP in 2022), but has fewer hospital beds and diagnostic tools, and pays nurses less.

Across the countries studied by the OECD in 2021, there were on average 4.3 hospital beds for every 1,000 in the population. But in the UK the figure was only 2.4 beds for every 1,000. Only Mexico, Costs Rica, Columbia, Chile, and Sweden, reported lower ratios.

So, what, if anything, can be done to improve things?

The first course of action should be to decide not to rule anything out. And yet that’s exactly what our politicians have always done.

Even when solutions are staring them in the face, they will insist that if it’s never been part of the NHS before, then it shouldn’t be in the future either. Even when other countries have successfully tried and tested those exact solutions.

The UK needs to be wiser about how to spend scarce resources. Every so often, a brave politician will tentatively suggest that patients should pay a small sum towards their GP appointments, or even be fined for failing to keep an appointment. But they are soon shouted down and told to behave themselves on pain of deselection or electoral defeat. The NHS is a political bargaining chip that is so entrenched with the electorate that political parties cannot budge over. Any governing party holds it as sacrosanct.

In Scotland, the introduction of free prescriptions for all was a major boost to the incomes of those already wealthy enough to pay for medicines. But woe betide any political party that might seek to reverse this redistribution of wealth from the poor to the rich.

Switching to a European-style social health insurance system would be no panacea – what works in one country could not be expected to work precisely the same way elsewhere.

But what does it say about the state of public debate in Britain that such a reform is immediately dismissed as being beyond the pale?

Germany, France, and Italy are hardly basket cases, or third world countries. Until two years ago, they were among our most important EU trading partners.

The question for policymakers should not be how best to preserve the NHS as it is, but rather how patients’ interests be prioritised?

The NHS was created to serve the country, not the other way around. It is not there to provide employment for its million-plus workforce. It is not there to create jobs for an army of administrators and bean counters.

And it certainly doesn’t exist to provide well-paid work for diversity, equity and inclusion officers, whose numbers have exploded in recent years with no measurable improvement in the quality of care given to patients as a result.

It exists for us, the UK citizens who pay for it with our taxes. That is its primary, if not its sole, function. And as the funders of the NHS, we should be insisting that it is no longer run in the shadow of a past that is viewed through rose-tinted glasses.

We should demand that it becomes a modern, flexible, dynamic, and innovative service.

We could start by shattering a central shibboleth of faith in the NHS: that privatisation is somehow alien to it, with its only aim to make profits from vulnerable patients.

In fact, the private sector is an essential mechanism for providing essential health services. Opticians and dentists, for example, earn much of their income from privately paying patients.

FOUR

EVEN local GP practices, our primary interface with the health service, are essentially private companies contracted to provide services to the NHS. No one in this country gets through life without dealing, at one point or another, with a private provider of healthcare services.

Institutional and financial reforms are necessary and inevitable at some point. But we as ordinary citizens must shoulder some of the responsibility for helping improve the nation’s health.

Far too often we have allowed politicians to convince us that our poor health – whether from being overweight, drinking too much alcohol, not taking enough exercise, or smoking – is not our responsibility, but is the fault, somehow, of the Government, or the food industry, or advertisers.

We are told to believe that we are powerless, susceptible to the diktats of these external forces.

We eat too much because planning laws allow too many fast-food restaurants to be built. We eat fatty, processed foods because we were never taught to cook properly at school. Many people smoke because they’re influenced by Hollywood stars doing the same on screen.

It’s all a big, dangerous lie. We choose what to eat and what lifestyles to pursue. If we rely on the Government to tell us how to live and to intervene to force us to make better choices, we surrender all responsibility for our own lives and our own health.

The combination is lethal. We rely on the Government to govern how we live and what we eat, and then demand that the health service we pay for through our taxes delivers better results, even as we rule out any kind of radical reform that might improve that healthcare system.

Standard