Arts, Drama, Screenplay

Body of Evidence: ‘The Defence Rests in Peace’

SERIES: CRIME FILE INVESTIGATIONS

Crime Scene

A series of crime scenes that will require the reader to apply their forensic skills in solving the mysteries.

CSI Wes Burton walked into the lawyer’s office and immediately bristled. It wasn’t seeing a corpse that disturbed him; it was the fact that he didn’t see one. The dozen or so people breathing in the room were obstructing his view.

“Which one of you is dead?” he asked. A stunned silence followed as the officers, emergency medical technicians and a short, shaken woman looked at him. “If it isn’t you, there’s no reason for you to be at the crime scene,” said Burton. Detective Erin Radley, who was used to his behaviour, tried to hide a smile.

As everyone filed out of the office, Burton took his custom-made “CRIME SCENE – DO NOT CROSS/CRIME SEEN? STICK AROUND” yellow tape out of pocket 2 of the fly fisherman’s waistcoat he wore to every crime scene. The 30 or so other pockets on the waistcoat bulged and rattled with everything from latex gloves to a handheld ultraviolet light. He rarely came across a situation that required something that wasn’t in those pockets. Radley stayed where she was, as far from the body as possible, to avoid further contaminating the scene. She had on her usual black leather jacket, and its mid-thigh length made her look even taller than usual.

One of the EMTs helped the distressed woman through the doorway. “We’ll check your heart rate right away, Miss Porter. I’m sure it’s nothing serious.” To Burton, he said, “She has some heart attack symptoms. If they continue, we’ll have to take her to the ER within A&E.”

Burton nodded. “Just keep all of her clothes, and don’t let her have a shower.” He stretched the yellow tape across the doorway and secured it. To him, that thin piece of plastic represented a brick wall with armed sentries on top. Maybe even a helicopter or two.

“What do we have, Detective Radley?” Burton asked as he made his way to the other side of the room, careful not to disturb anything. The two client chairs in front of the desk seemed in place, but until photographs were taken, nothing could be moved. Not moving wouldn’t be a problem for Brent Cordova, former lawyer, who was face up on the floor behind his enormous desk.

“Dead lawyer,” she said, opening her notepad. “Only a few million suspects.”

“Shotgun to the chest?” Burton asked.

“Looks like it,” Radley said. “The legal assistant, Miss Porter, says that Cordova had been planning on closing his practice and retiring next month, and he was handing off all his defence cases on a first-come, first-served basis. She says the clients weren’t happy and have been calling with nasty messages.”

“He didn’t know making murder suspects angry can have bad side effects?” Burton asked. “Like getting murdered?”

“You’d think he would,” Radley said. “Only three of his current clients are on trial for murder, and they’re being tracked down right now. We’ll see how their alibis look.” Radley thought for a moment, then went on. “If one of them did it, I hope he’ll talk to me about why.”

“Are you still writing that book of yours?” Burton asked.

“Yes,” she said. “I’ve got some fascinating stuff so far.” Radley, who had a master’s degree in psychology, had been compiling case studies for years that focus on why criminals commit their crimes. She planned to publish them for the law enforcement community.

“I still don’t get it,” Burton said. “The why doesn’t prove anything. You can’t convict anyone on a reason or motive; you have to know how they did it.”

“True,” Radley said. “But if we find out why a murder took place, maybe we can prevent the next one from happening at all.”

“But people can lie about why they did something,” Burton said, “and you might not be able to prove that they’re lying. Evidence stands up in court. It does not lie.”

“So you’re always telling me,” said Radley.

Burton took a closer look at the entrance wound on the body. It was on Cordova’s upper left chest, with gunshot residue and small burns on his skin and the tatters of his shirt. There was no visible exit of pellets or slugs, but from the pattern and depth of the wound, he could see that the shot had entered at a 10-degree angle from Cordova’s left side, at about the height of his shoulder.

Burton also saw that Cordova’s chair, a highbacked leather throne, had gunshot residue on the upper left wing. “How tall are those three murder suspects?”

Radley pulled three folders from under her arm and checked through them. “Miss Porter pulled these for me. She’s pretty upset. She passed the bar exam a month ago and has helped with some of these cases. She thinks if the killer comes back, she’ll be next.”

“Did she witness anything?” Burton asked.

“No, she says she found him like this, called us right away. OK, here’s the last one. The suspects are six-foot-three, five-foot-ten and six foot. Is that helpful?”

“Not to the shooter’s case,” Burton said.

The EMT stuck his head in over the crime scene tape. “Miss Porter’s having some real trouble out here. Heart’s racing like a jack rabbit. We’re going to take her to the hospital for observation.”

“That’s fine,” Burton said. “But let Detective Radley read her her rights first.”

How did he know?

Solution The Defence Rests In Peace

CI2

Standard
Arts, Books, Medical, Society, Syria

Book Review – War Doctor: Surgery On The Front Line

MEMOIR

Syria, 2012 – Location: Atmeh. A woman was rushed to the operating theatre with severe bomb damage to her leg.

Dr David Nott, a trauma surgeon, clamped the artery to prevent her from bleeding to death and gently pressed a finger into the gaping hole above her knee joint. He felt an object. It was probably some kind of shrapnel, but it was strangely smooth and cylindrical.

Dr Nott grabbed it with his fingers – “very carefully”, he recalls – and pulled it out. Once extracted he held it up to examine it. His Syrian helper took one look and went visibly pale; he obviously knew what was being presented and blurted out, “Mufajir!” before turning tail and leaving the room.

Nott and the anaesthetist locked eyes in panic. Was this some kind of bomb? The room fell silent, bar the hiss of the patient’s ventilator. The anaesthetist backed away and Nott felt his hand begin to shake so vigorously, he was in danger of dropping the thing.

Then the Syrian helper rushed back in with a bucket of water and motioned for Nott to place the metal object carefully into the bottom of it. He later learned that “mufajir” means “detonator” and it could have blown off his hand.

The woman was injured when a bomb her husband had been making in their kitchen had prematurely detonated, killing him instantly.

You can sense Dr Nott’s frustration and anger at the speed with which the Syrian civil war escalated. It had begun in March 2011, when a peaceful protest against the oppressive regime of Bashar al-Assad was met with shocking brutality.

By chance, Nott had met al-Assad in the early 1990s, when the dictator-in-waiting was working as an ophthalmic senior house officer at the Western Eye Hospital, London.

“He seemed very pleasant and respectful,” recalls the surgeon who would later treat Assad’s victims, including a heavily pregnant woman whose unborn child had been shot through the head by a sniper.

In his devastating memoir of more than two decades volunteering his services in some of the world’s most dangerous places, Nott doesn’t speculate on what changed al-Assad’s attitude to his fellow human beings.

He does, however, pinpoint the precise moment that a shy boy from rural Wales realised he wanted to become a “war doctor”, his epiphany occurring in 1985 when he first qualified as a surgeon. His parents took him to the cinema to see The Killing Fields (Roland Joffe’s 1984 drama about the civil war in Cambodia).

Nott’s father, also a doctor, was born in Burma and Nott had endured racist bullying as a child.

“The film lit a torch in me,” he says. “I could relate to its themes of innocent people being bullied, pushed around or dismissed. It gave a vivid depiction of the horrors of war. But, more than that, the film depicted the incredible power of human love in the face of unimaginable adversity.”

Some eight years later, Nott was standing over an operating table in Sarajevo. He had taken a month’s unpaid leave from the NHS to volunteer for the French aid organisation Médecins Sans Frontieres. The Bosnian civil war opened his eyes to a new medicine, in which decisions had to be made quickly, without the diagnostic tests and specialist equipment on which he had come to depend.

“I had never seen injuries like the ones that were coming in every hour.”

 

THE damage inflicted by bombs and high-velocity bullets was of an entirely different order from those received in even the most catastrophic trauma car accidents.

Multiple limbs were often missing. Many patients were dead on arrival, accompanied by relatives begging for help that Nott could not provide.

When he could attempt surgery, the hospital generators would often fail, and the team would have to wait until a porter brought in a wheelbarrow full of car batteries to get the theatre functioning again.

When bombs fell on the hospital itself, Nott’s team fled, leaving him alone in the dark, his hands around the failing heart of a teenage boy.

Stumbling from the room, soaked in his patient’s blood, Nott felt angry and betrayed. But he soon learned that, as an aid worker, his first duty was to keep himself alive so that he could help more people.

It was the first of many difficult moral choices he would have to make in Afghanistan, Sierra Leone, Chad, the Ivory Coast, Libya, Gaza, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Iraq and Pakistan.

In his scrubs, would you defy the Taliban policeman forbidding you to treat a woman bleeding to death in childbirth? Would you save the life of an ISIS fundamentalist likely to kidnap you on recovery? Would you give money to the children of dead patients?

Dr Nott had to make all these calls under extraordinary pressure.

He describes numerous near-death experiences and there was some terrible emotional fallout.

After returning from one mission, Nott found himself unable to bear the complaints of a British patient fretting about her “unsightly” thread veins and began a screaming, feigned sciatic attack until she left his consulting room.

He also had a panic attack when invited to a private lunch with the Queen. Overwhelmed by the contrast between the luxury of Buckingham Palace and the desolation he had seen in Syria, Nott found himself unable to answer Her Majesty’s questions.

As visions of limbless children filled his head, she placed her hand gently on his and encouraged him to pet her dogs. “There,” she said. “That’s so much better than talking, isn’t it.”

These days, the 63-year-old medic still travels the world to help victims of disaster. But his priorities changed after meeting his wife, Elly, at a charity event for Syria Relief in 2013.

The relationship came as a “bolt from the blue” to the man with a “monastic existence”. But, before they could arrange a first date, Nott made a trip to Gaza, where he elected to stay in the operating theatre to save the life of a little girl called Aysha, even though he had been ordered to evacuate the hospital because an airstrike was expected in minutes.

It was a story that Dr Nott told on Radio 4’s Desert Island Discs in 2017, reducing listeners to tears as he described how he still treasures the photograph he has of her, smiling as she recovered.

David married Elly in 2015 and welcomed daughter Molly the same year. Elly – an Oxford graduate with an MA in international relations – was the chief executive of the David Nott Foundation (a charity training surgeons to work in conflict zones) until the beginning of 2019.

Although as a husband and father, Nott tries harder to avoid danger, he finds it hard to be optimistic about the situation in Syria.

But he remains committed in continuing to train doctors working there.

On the final page of his book, Nott quotes the Koran: “Whoever saves a life, it shall be as though he had saved the lives of all mankind.”

– (Memoir) War Doctor: Surgery On The Front Line by David Nott is published by Picador for £18.99, 304pp

Standard
Britain, Government, Legal, Military

Criminal probe launched into bullying at military base

BRITAIN

Intro: 24 years after historic allegations of abuse at Deepcut military barracks, a criminal probe is launched by Surrey Police

POLICE have launched a criminal investigation into assault allegations surrounding the suicide of a young soldier at the notorious Deepcut barracks almost 24 years ago.

Private Sean Benton, 20, was the first of four British soldiers to die in shootings at the Princess Royal Barracks in Surrey between 1995 and 2002 amid claims of bullying from more senior soldiers and other recruits.

A fresh inquest into Private Benton’s 1995 death ruled last year that he killed himself after being subjected to physical and psychological abuse.

He was found with five bullet wounds to the chest days after being “punched and kicked” by an instructor, leading to calls for a criminal prosecution.

Now, having reviewed evidence from the inquest in Woking, police have opened a new probe into allegations of assault and misconduct in public office.

The investigation was launched in October and has emerged as a fresh inquest into the death of another private, Geoff Gray, was opened earlier this week. It will cover a period from the mid-1990s to the early 2000s.

A spokesperson said: “Surrey Police reviewed the findings [of] the coroner and the Benton family’s request for a new criminal investigation into allegations including assault and misconduct in public office.

“A criminal investigation is under way into a number of allegations.” Three other recruits – Private Cheryl James, 18, Private Gray, 17, and Private James Collinson, 17 – also died at the base between 1995 and 2002 amid claims of bullying and abuse.

Private Collinson, from Perth, was the fourth person to die at the barracks. He was found dead with a single gunshot wound through his chin on March 23, 2002. An inquest into his death in 2006 returned an open verdict.

The coroner at Private Benton’s inquest, Peter Rook QC, delivered a damning five-hour narrative verdict of suicide last June, describing the harsh treatment the soldier was subjected to at the barracks.

He said: “There was a toxic culture at Deepcut at which Sean was frequently the recipient of actions.” He added that Private Benton was often on the receiving end of punishments by senior officers.

The court heard that the recruit was ordered to carry out degrading exercises by one non-commissioned officer, Sergeant Andrew Gavaghan, who has repeatedly denied allegations of abusive behaviour.

This included Private Benton having to perform press-ups on top of a female lance corporal in front of other recruits.

The court heard how a week before the death in June 1995, Sergeant Gavaghan kicked the soldier as he did press-ups.

Mr Rook added: “At times he [Sergeant Gavaghan] did lose control of himself.”

The coroner noted that Private Benton was told he was due to be discharged from the Army after a series of disciplinary problems and his feelings of shame had contributed to his state of mind.

His original inquest was held a month after his death and recorded a verdict of suicide.

But Private Benton’s family wanted the fresh inquest after allegations of bullying and a cover-up emerged at Deepcut.

The coroner also described a litany of failures with the original “woefully inadequate” police inquiry. Shortly after the inquest began, the Army apologised and said there were “a number of things that could and should have been better”.

The second inquest into the death of Private Gray has been launched after a campaign by his parents.

Standard