Arts, Books, History

Book Review: In Rome’s Long Shadow

LITERARY REVIEW

Intro: Ancient Rome offers many valuable lessons about how to safeguard democracy. History shows us there is only one way to avoid tyranny – and that’s through free speech

We all know of the adage “history repeats itself”. And historians have been repeating that cliché ever since Classical times.

For Roman historians like Livy, history was full of brief anecdotes and illustrations, showing what true tyranny looks like, how freedom is won, and what it takes to sustain a decent political system.

History should never be seen as a dry chronicle of dates and events: we should learn from it about human heroism and triumph, as well as idiocy and wickedness, and then practice and exercise the good from what we’ve learned.

This is the central theme at the heart of this book by Jamie Gianoutsos, an intellectually demanding but fascinating overview of how Rome faced the same problems as we do, dealt with them (or failed to), and inspired later rulers, from the Italian Renaissance to America’s Founding Fathers.

The latter were so obsessed with Rome they created Senators and diplomatic Consuls. Even now, Washington’s political centre brims with “Corinthian columns and toga-styled statues”.

Key themes

Eschewing straight narrative, the book examines key themes: liberty and slavery, women and the republic, tyranny and lust.

The Roman republic was born out of a horrific rape, and they never forgot it. The last tyrant-king was Tarquinius Superbus, whose son committed this vile and horrific crime against the virtuous Lucretia, another man’s wife.

Before stabbing herself to death, Lucretia cried out for vengeance, whereupon her cousin verbally snapped at her mourners to “Trade your tears for marching. Act like men!”. Very Roman.

The corrupt last kings of Rome were duly chased from the city, and Rome became a proud republic – until Augustus, and the return of the emperors.

For the freedom-loving Romans of the old republic then, those who lorded it over the people without their consent were symbolically described as rapists. That’s an extraordinary and disturbing image, but one that inspired the American republicans fighting British rule in the 18th century.

They castigated Britain for ravishing the innocent land of America, and when opposing one of Britain’s Coercive Acts, in 1774, a shocking cartoon was published showing prime minister Lord North forcibly pouring the hated and heavily-taxed British tea down the throat of a Native American girl. It was ferocious political propaganda – and it worked.

The Romans saw there were three forms of government, all of which have a dark shadow: monarchy, which can denigrate into tyranny; aristocracy, literally “rule by the best,” which can become a corrupt self-serving elite or oligarchy; and democracy, which can become mob rule by an ignorant, bullying majority. In fact, some like the historian Tacitus, believed that all three are bound to deteriorate into their shadow versions.

Democracries always turn self-indulgent until the Strong Man rises to impose law and order, and the cycle begins again.

Roman historian Livy warned about certain societies which appear to be “in love with death both individual and collective”, and are doomed to be replaced.

There’s a riveting chapter on the connection between democracy and free speech: one cannot exist without the other.

After the rise of the emperors, books were burned and writers like poor old Ovid, the poet, were exiled to the Black Sea coast.

Under the austere but freedom-loving old Roman republic, freedom of speech was protected to the hilt: all speech, without qualification. There was no State police force, the author reminds us, nor censors. Even plain invective and abuse were fine: Cicero once called an opponent in a law court a “bastard”. No one objected. Deeds might be illegal, but mere words never could be.

This example inspired the republicans of 17th-century England, like the poet John Milton, who insisted that “for the truth to be reached, all opinions must be voiced freely”.

It also gave rise to the first recognisable newspapers, but not without insult as they were denigrated as “this moth-eating crew of newsmongers” – perhaps the first (but not the last) rant slung at those wretched journalists. But newspapers became essential in informing the people.

False facts

Over in America a century later, Founding Fathers Thomas Jefferson and James Madison privately discussed “private facts” – what we would now call fake news or misinformation. In the name of freedom, they defended the right to publish even these.

In 1798, the States passed a Sedition Act, which condemned anyone who dared “write, print, utter or publish . . . any false, scandalous and malicious writings against the government”. Jefferson was horrified, and the Act expired in 1801. Falsehoods and malice were seen as the price you paid for freedom.

In Rome’s Long Shadow the narrative shows how today’s troublesome issues were long-since debated, though not solved, by some of the most influential historical figures.

– In Rome’s Long Shadow by Jamie Gianoutos, is published by Allen Lane, 384pp

Standard
Arts, Books, Psychology, Science

Book Review: Agency

LITERARY REVIEW

Intro: The father of positive psychology, Martin Seligman, offers a three-step plan that means you can take control of your own destiny

Shakespeare got it right: “All things be ready, if our minds be so,” says King Harry in Henry V. The scene depicts the English being vastly outnumbered by French forces, but he has no doubt what will bring about an English victory on St Crispin’s Day.

Sheer will, he tells the assembled Lords. Will is at the root of agency; willpower drives performance and success. Even in these depressed and uncertain times, that seems self-evident.

Over a half-a-century ago, however, the world-renowned psychologist, Martin Seligman, witnessed the collapse of will in his best student at Cornell University.

Faced with a project well within her capabilities she simply gave up, because she had convinced herself she couldn’t do it.

Her professor realised that, “in 1968, psychology had no vocabulary for what I wanted to say”.

For even the rival “camps” in his subject agreed on one thing: “Free will was an illusion. People were products – of conditioning, of unconscious drives, or forces beyond their control.”

It became Seligman’s mission to identify, “the most important force in human experience: agency – the belief that you can influence your own future”. He thought of his brilliant student giving up and wondered if she might have been able to learn how to persist, how to strive for what seemed impossible, and how to resist her own sense of inadequacy.

“Agency”, he writes, is “the audacious human belief that tomorrow can be better than today, and that we have the power to make it so.”

Seligman is widely respected as the founder of positive psychology – the scientific study of what makes life worth living and what can make people thrive.

He is known for his inspiring works on happiness, optimism, change, and wellbeing – yet he is most emphatically not to be mistaken for a self-help guru or therapist.

His bracing view that individuals can take control of their own lives is central. This hard-won optimism counters his own natural depressive tendencies by focusing on human strength, not weakness – as he insists, the most effective way to become more optimistic is through “mental toughness”.

Strict scientific data underpins whatever motivational advice readers may take from his many books.

This latest volume is perhaps the most ambitious, embracing a vast sweep of human history in order to assess how “agency” affects human progress and survival.

There are lessons for the individual in his analysis of why some societies thrive, why some flounder, and how whole civilisations can be swept away.

Seligman admits to being a pessimist himself, which perhaps explains his life’s work as a personal pep talk.

He identifies three elements that combine to form the energy behind “the belief that I can achieve my goals” – which is the agency driving the human spirit.

1. Efficacy is “my estimate of achieving a specific goal in the here and now”. 2. Optimism is about “achievement in the future”. 3. Imagination is “my mental representation of the range of goals I can achieve beyond the here and now”.

That three-step works on a personal level. But the whole drive of the book is societal too: “Efficacy causes trying hard, optimism causes persistence, and imagination causes innovation. This is exactly how agency causes progress.”

This is the core belief of the book. Without agency there is no action.

When a society is confident and forward-looking, progress occurs. When it is absent the result is stagnation – a malaise which, incidentally, some readers may recognise in Britain today.

TWO

To illustrate his theory, Seligman conducts us on an exhilarating whistlestop tour through human history, seeking answers to the question, “Why some [people] crumble under life’s blows while others bounce back.”

Why are some individuals resilient while others exhibit “Learned Helplessness”? How does that play out across a whole culture? Is it inevitably true that “poverty . . . causes present-mindedness and wealth causes future-mindedness”? What does rigorous belief in an ideology or religion do to human agency? Just some of the fascinating and vital questions Seligman poses in this hugely important book.

His answers are to be found in history. He examines the later books of the Hebrew Bible and makes a comparison between their growth of human agency, and the writings of the Zhou Dynasty in China and the Golden Age of Greece: “Three unrelated civilisations across the globe and within a broadly comparable period, recognise the power of human agency and their gods retreat.”  

He compares the development of those three different cultures and observes that their Golden periods of success arrived once people had lessened their slavish belief in gods as the source of power, who therefore had to be obeyed. “When we mortals are thought to control our destiny, we actually do. When supernatural forces . . . are thought to control our destiny, we languish,” he notes. Readers should be reminded this is a book written by a psychologist.

Technology allows Seligman to dissect language, listing “agentic” words of action and determination and hope used through key texts and documents, which indicate the states of mind of individuals and societies.

After a cheerful and useful chapter called More Agency In Your Life (tips on how to learn optimism), Seligman does an extraordinary thing.

This brilliant book about human agency ends with what some critics’ regard as a kowtow to Artificial Intelligence (AI). He even shows how it can take his place in solving problems.

I did wonder if it had infected the brilliant brain of a man who has sought nothing but good, yet fails to grasp the obvious peril that the will of AI will banish human agency altogether.

– Agency by Martin Seligman is published by John Murray One, 400pp

Standard
Arts, Books, Literature

Book Review: Land by Maggie O’Farrell

LITERARY REVIEW

Intro: Set in the decades after the Great Hunger, “Land” is a rich portrait of family life amid Ireland’s long struggle against British rule

Cartography has never been a neutral discipline. Maps offer a partial view of a landscape, informed by what the mapmaker wishes the reader to see. A colonising army will mark the features of the terrain that serves its purposes and exclude inconvenient signs of prior habitation. And they will do this in their own language.

“Land”, Maggie O’Farrell’s 10th novel, is set in Ireland in the 1860s. It has been more than a decade since the Great Hunger killed over a million people and forced an even higher number into exile, and the landscape is dotted with empty villages and over-full graves. Tomás – an Irish cartographer working for the British “redcoats” – and his young son, Liam, are charting a remote peninsula on the country’s west coast when Tomás has a sudden, revelatory experience at a pre-Christian holy spring.

What he encounters there inspires him to abandon his office job and counter the efforts of his erstwhile employers by drawing his own, dissident map of the area. It will reconstitute the terrain as its inhabitants understand it, in their language, honouring the communities that have been annihilated, the woods and waterways that rightly belong to them, and the old cultural landmarks the British have no use for.

The task, for Tomás, is personal: both he and his wife, Phina, were orphans of the Hunger, forced from their rural lives into urban workhouses. He moves his family from Dublin to the countryside as an act of reclamation and renewal. Phina, however, is more ambivalent. She worries about money now that her husband has foregone his regular salary, and about her daughters’ future prospects given that in their new village Catholic schooling is reserved for boys.

Like much of the author’s previous work, including her most famous, the 2020 book “Hamnet” – adapted into a 2025 film by Chloé Zhao – “Land” is a historical novel with O’Farrell’s signature interest in absorbing family relationships. The first half of the narrative sows the seeds of a defiant, multigenerational reckoning with the British Empire, and to an extent the Catholic Church. We encounter a windswept landscape; a menacing, nameless viscount; a kindly widow who represents all the grieving folk of the land; and a condescending priest. O’Farrell takes us on a lively deep dive into the land’s prehistory – a place of hill forts, druids, wanderers and wolfhounds, where virgins are ritually sacrificed to stave off bad weather.

Great period novels balance larger historical context with personal details and textures, and at first “Land” feels poised to do just that, deftly situating a rich portrait of family life amid Ireland’s centuries-long struggle against British rule.

But as the novel proceeds, this promise largely dissolves. Tomás’s cartographic ambitions, initially presented as the story’s engine, fall from focus as the story shifts to his children’s comings of age and their own varied relationships to the Irish diaspora across the British Empire.

Unfortunately, O’Farrell leaves these relationships and their wider ramifications mostly unexplored. Liam joins the Jesuits and travels as a missionary to South India, where he briefly considers the connection between his role and that of the British in Ireland, but ultimately loses his faith because of homesickness rather than any true engagement with the locals’ plight.

– A sweeping historical family saga set primarily in post-Famine Ireland. The novel blends themes of cartography, colonialism, family bonds, and the deep connection between people and the land

His sister Enda journeys to Quebec on an emigration permit she’s stolen from Liam, and struggles to make a living there as a domestic labourer and street musician. She meets her love interest in the immigration line: an Eastern European teacher turned cook who picks up work as a logger in the summers to make enough money to bring the rest of his family to Canada. But the novel pulls its punches when it comes to the parallels between deforestation in the Americas and that in Ireland.

Nonetheless, O’Farrell’s writing is propulsive and luscious throughout, and there are some emotive and moving passages told from the perspective of Phina’s nonverbal youngest child, Eugene. But the problems with “Land” stem from its reluctance to question the moral clarity of its core characters. They are all unimpeachably good. Tomás loses his grip on reality, and their other daughter, Rose, resents her siblings for leaving her behind on the peninsula; but the real darkness in the novel lies outside the family unit – with the redcoats, the viscount, and the church. The evils of imperialism do not require its victims, real or imagined, to be pure and incorruptible, especially when their own migrations make them the dominant presence in other colonies.

At its best, “Land” evokes weighty, time-slip novels like Alan Garner’s “Red Shift”, drawing associative lines across eras and grappling with the long afterlives of colonial violence. But there is no doubt it is deflated by characters whose confrontations with the forces around them are too shallow to constitute a serious reckoning with the moral dilemmas the novel poses at the start.

– Land by Maggie O’Farrell is published by Knopf (an imprint of Penguin), 384pp

Standard