Britain, Government, Health, Medical, Society

One of Britain’s top medics says we need an NHS fit for the modern age

NATIONAL HEALTH SERVICE

PROFESSOR Stephen Smith, Dean of Medicine at Imperial College London, has been making his professional views known on the state of the NHS. The leading medic says that the service will never improve until the entire system has had radical surgery. In a brilliantly argued prognosis, Professor Smith has seen first-hand how the rest of the world almost always delivers better health care and says it is not about the money.

As a consultant gynaecologist and professor, he once advocated a change in the appointments system at one of the best hospitals in the country – the Rosie Hospital which is part of Addenbrooke’s in Cambridge.

The existing arrangements saw one batch of women called in at 9am, another at 11.30am. The medic became increasingly tired of seeing these patients sitting in the waiting area, often agitated and fed up.

He cites a woman who comes through the door having been made to wait for more than two hours and who is understandably angry, tired and resentful, especially as she’d been trying to entertain a screaming three-year-old. The clinician says you’re not going to get the best account of someone’s medical history in those circumstances.

He thought individual appointment times would be better: say, one every 15 minutes. Every doctor and patient he spoke to agreed.

You would think it easy to get things done for someone who is a professor in the NHS. Senior doctors are revered: their opinion and judgements count. But try to actually change anything and it’s a different story.

Naively, Professor Smith thought the switch to a 15-minute appointment system would be easy. Instead, he had to argue his case in front of at least six committees who each have a separate chairman and differing agendas.

That instance was just the first of many of his battles with the staggering bureaucracy within the NHS.

Next, his unit pioneered a scheme whereby pregnant women would carry their own medical records to appointments instead of looking up their records on the central database. The opposition to this was ferocious.

TWO

PROFESSOR SMITH’S unit pointed out that 17 per cent of central records could not be found. And once women were trusted with their own notes, only 5 per cent turned up without them.

He also mentions another arduous battle in which post-appointment letters are sent to the patient, with a copy to their GP – instead of the other way round.

At the heart of this chaos, he says, is a system that doesn’t put the patient first. The hurdles placed in the way of reform are designed to shore up the NHS – and are not in the best interests of the people who need it.

After Cambridge, Professor Smith became Dean of Medicine at Imperial College London, then CEO of the Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust. He has also worked in Singapore and Australia.

Having had a view of our healthcare system from many perspectives, today’s NHS, he says, is simply not fit for purpose.

The additional funds the Government is about to direct to the NHS – some £36 billion over three years thanks to a new “Health and Social Care Levy”, including £5.4 billion to help clear the backlog caused by Covid – is well intentioned. But throwing money at the current system won’t get us anywhere.

We have been furnished with yet more stark reminders of the eye-watering sums the NHS is capable of wasting. It reportedly paid around £400 million a month last summer to block-book private hospital care for non-Covid patients.

A good idea, many might think. But astonishingly two-thirds of that went unused, perhaps for ideological reasons. Many NHS staff have an aversion to private medicine.

Meanwhile, waiting lists have grown. About 5.6 million people are waiting for hospital treatment, and that number looks set to double in the coming years.

Some £9 million of the new money is already earmarked for salaries of up to £270,000 for executives who will be expected to “actively champion diversity, inclusion and equality of opportunity”.

The medic says he has no quarrel with high salaries if they help to attract highly competent people. These are, after all, important jobs. When Professor Smith was chief executive at Imperial College, he was responsible for a £1.2 billion-a-year budget and had people’s lives at stake.

His prognosis says it’s time we had a major review of the way we run our health service. The NHS was born from such a review: the famous 1942 Beveridge Report, which looked at health care, social care and education. It was marvellous and set up an NHS that was suited to life 80 years ago.

We need now to set up a new Beveridge review. A national debate should be had about how to best fund and run our health service for the 21st century.

The review could be a Royal Commission, it could be an inquiry led by a judge. But, he says, any inquiry should typically involve medical personnel, economists, social-care experts, politicians, and patients, while avoiding childish, political squabbles. And we need to ask: what do we want, and how do we pay for it?

Professor Smith’s analysis says there are other, far better ways in which we can pay for healthcare in this country. The best would be the social insurance schemes seen elsewhere in the developed world – which would offer a vastly superior service than the one we have now.

The biggest obstacle to bringing in social insurance is actually the English language. When you mention social insurance, people in Britain almost freeze. They think: “I can’t afford medical insurance!”

But it’s not at all like private medical insurance – that’s completely misleading.

Under a social insurance scheme, the Government “hypothecates” – that is, promises – the money to go on healthcare. The scheme is then run-on insurance principles, but it’s paid for by the state out of taxation. And the money cannot be used for anything else.

Be wary of the objections from the Department of Health and the Treasury that social insurance is complicated and difficult to manage. We know through international comparisons that it provides a high standard of care – often higher than the NHS.

Many will have been cheered to see that the levy the prime minister announced last week will be hypothecated for health and social care. That’s a small step towards a proper system of social insurance.

THREE

THIS has nothing to do with “privatising” the health service, nor is it a criticism of our health professionals who have shown – especially over the past two years – selfless dedication. It is about dramatically improving healthcare in this country.

The great myth about the NHS is the belief that, because it provides for everyone, it is exceptional. But do people here seriously think the citizens of Belgium, Holland, Germany, New Zealand, Australia, Canada, Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark, Norway, Spain and Italy all go around worrying about whether they will get treatment for any condition they may have? Of course not.

All these countries have slightly different systems, so our NHS review could look at the right mix of options, taking ideas from several countries, perhaps, to get the best for the UK. 

Professor Smith highlights the Dutch system, which has a small number of sickness funds which patients can switch between without penalty.

As a nation, the medic says, we’ve set the bar far too low: grateful to see a GP after several weeks’ wait, grateful to have surgery, if only after the millions ahead of us on the waiting list have had theirs.

The truth is, he insists, is that we can do better.

Explaining that when he was a young doctor, the clinician was filled with fervour for the NHS. He had the fiercest arguments, insisting our system was the best in the world. Then he began travelling to other countries as part of his academic research into menstrual dysfunction.

Much of his early research was done in Sweden. That was his first eye-opener: the Swedish system was outstanding.

One of the first things that impressed him was that consultants went outside their hospitals and held clinics in GP surgeries.

That was enlightening and certainly new to him. In Sweden, the consultant was expected to go to the patient, not the other way round. That is still a feature of Swedish medicine and we should look at it closely.

Right now, too much in healthcare isn’t right for the patient but persists because “we’ve always done it this way”.

And as for privatisation? When people talk of “mixing public with private”, there’s a widespread suspicion that evil American corporations will descend and make huge profits from “our” precious NHS.

But – and here’s the key point – large parts of the NHS are already private.

In the many years of working in hospitals, Professor Smith has never understood why so many people haven’t realised that GPs don’t actually work for the health service. They are small businesses. So are dentists, including those offering NHS care.

The first criticism from the Left is always, “Look at the American system!”

Professor Smith acknowledges that the American system is atrocious – not to mention terrible value for money. Many people live in fear of not being able to pay their medical bills and care costs twice as much as anywhere else in the world. Nobody wants that. What would improve Britain’s healthcare is a system like those of many of our European neighbours.

The biggest challenge for the UK health service now is how to integrate primary care (GPs, dentists and opticians) with secondary care (including hospitals). This comes naturally in a less “top-down” social-insurance system.

FOUR

SOCIAL CARE has long been neglected, but it is key to making the whole system work. It’s about getting older and vulnerable people home from hospital, rather than leaving them stuck there when they no longer need to be.

If Mrs Jones, 95, is ready to be discharged but social care can’t ensure she will be looked after at home, she must stay in hospital. Then the bed she would have vacated is not available for the next person needing an operation, and so on…

Lack of integration in the NHS is systemic: most patients are astonished, the professor says, at the difficulty of sharing records between a hospital and general practice.

The clinician says that if you are assessing someone’s health needs, you should be able, with their consent, to access their primary care records, operation notes and anything else that is relevant. But this is very difficult – although technology is slowly improving matters.

Professor Smith poses a final question. Should we now change the role of GPs to focus more on long-term care?

The medic says that if you are a woman with problem periods, say, why shouldn’t you access an app, put in your medical history and refer yourself to a consultant whose team will be able to look at the problem and decide if you need to come and see them? Why should your GP be the only port of call?

This final point brings Professor Smith back to his key point. The NHS as we have it was designed for life 80 years ago, when your GP was the person – invariably a man, in those days – who acted as a gatekeeper.

That was then, he says. What we need now is an NHS for the current and modern era.

Standard
Health, Medical, Research

New Alzheimer’s drug offers hope to sufferers

DEMENTIA/ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE

THE first new pharmaceutical drug for Alzheimer’s in almost two decades has won approval in the United States – raising hopes that the drug could soon be used in the UK.

Aducanumab targets the cause of the disease rather than its symptoms.

Medical and health charities have welcomed the announcement, describing its approval as a “major milestone” for the millions of people living with dementia. But scientists are divided because of the uncertainty over trial results.

The US Food and Drug Administration said there was “substantial evidence that aducanumab reduces amyloid beta plaques”. Amyloid is a protein that forms clumps in the brain that can damage cells and trigger dementia. Aducanumab works by sticking to these clumps and removing them.

However, late-stage international trials of the treatment in 2019, involving about 3,000 patients, were halted when analysis showed the drug was no better at slowing the deterioration of memory than a placebo. Following further analysis, manufacturer Biogen said the drug did work and significantly slowed cognitive decline if given in higher doses.

Biogen have not released the cost of the treatment, but analysts estimate it could cost up to £35,000 a year. Tens of thousands of Britons with a mild form of the disease could be suitable for the drug if it were to be approved here.

Professor Bart De Strooper, director the UK Dementia Research Institute, said: “With no effective therapies currently available to modify the progression of this devastating condition, this is a major milestone for the millions of people living with Alzheimer’s. However, I fear the controversy and uncertainty surrounding the trials will limit the impact of this new treatment for the disease.”

A spokesperson for the research department at the Alzheimer’s Society, said: “It’s promising to see that aducanumab has been approved for use in people with early-stage Alzheimer’s disease – the first drug to be approved in nearly 20 years by the US regulatory authorities.

“We await the opinion of the European Medicines Agency and the outcome of any application made to the UK regulatory authorities, to give clarity to people with early Alzheimer’s disease in the UK. Whatever the outcome of their decision, this is just the beginning of the road to new treatments for Alzheimer’s disease.”

Another health charity, Alzheimer’s Research UK, said it had written to UK Health Secretary Matt Hancock asking the Government to prioritise the fast-track approval process for the drug in the UK.

Its chief executive, Hilary Evans, said: “People with dementia and their families have been waiting far too long for life-changing new treatments.”

Standard
Health, Psychology, Research, Science

Positive Psychology: Barriers to well-being

BARRIERS TO HAPPINESS AND WELLBEING

ON May 9, 2021, an entry was made on this site concerning ‘happiness’ and the factors that can affect it. You might like to refer back to it.

The article looked at various tried and tested pathways to happiness, such as the five components of Martin Seligman’s well-being theory: positive emotion, engagement, relationships, meaning and accomplishment.

But is happiness that easy to attain? Surely if it were that simple, we’d all feel pretty upbeat all the time. In practice, there are several psychological obstacles which stand in the way of us achieving long-lasting happiness and contentment, and it’s worth knowing what these are so that we can try to overcome them. This entry will explore the five main barriers to well-being.

Barrier 1: the negativity bias

The negativity bias refers to our tendency to pay more attention and give more weight to negative emotions, experiences, and information than to positive ones. This means that you’re more likely to remember (and take seriously) an insult, a criticism or a piece of negative information or feedback than a compliment or a piece of positive information or feedback. From an evolutionary perspective this makes perfect sense since we would not have survived as a species had we not been finely attuned to notice the actual dangers and possible risks all around us. But now that there are far fewer threats in our lives (whatever the media says), this in-built negativity bias can get in the way of our well-being.

Studies also show that positive and negative information of the same importance do not hold equal weight in our minds. If we are given two pieces of equally important information about a stranger, one positive and one negative, they don’t balance each other out – we’re more likely to form a negative view of the person than a neutral one. Similarly, if we have had a good experience and bad experience close together, we will feel worse than neutral, even if the two experiences are of a similar importance. The evidence suggests that positive and negative emotions are not equal, or, in other words, negative emotions reduce our level of well-being more than positive emotions increase it. This helps to explain why it is important to experience positive emotions frequently.

Psychologist Roy Baumeister and colleagues summed up the impact of the negativity bias in five words: “bad is stronger than good.”

Barrier 2: duration neglect

It seems logical that the duration of an experience should influence how we feel about it and how we remember it. A two-week holiday in the sunshine on a glorious tropical island should feel twice as good as exactly the same holiday in the same location lasting for one week. Likewise, undergoing a negative experience such as a 20-minute dental procedure should feel twice as bad as a 10-minute procedure, assuming we feel the same intensity of discomfort throughout both.

So, it may surprise you to discover that when we evaluate our positive and negative experiences, their duration hardly matters at all, which psychologists call duration neglect. Factors which are considered more important are, 1) the intensity of the peak positive or negative emotion, and 2) how the experience ends. So, if we undergo a painful medical procedure which lasts 20 minutes, as long as the pain we experience at the end is less severe than our worst experience of pain during the procedure, we’ll actually remember it more favourably than the same procedure in which the worst pain is the same, but which is only half as long.

In practice this means that if we want to increase our well-being, and that of other people, we should deliberately look for ways to end experiences on a high note. This might just be a simple thing such as when leaving work at the end of the week, you wish colleagues a good weekend. Or, if you have to do something like a presentation, make sure you end it on a high, and practise a positive ending until it comes naturally.

Barrier 3: social comparison

We use the expression “keeping up with the Joneses” to refer to the comparison we make with others – such as our neighbours – to determine how well we’re doing in life. If we buy things to keep up with the Joneses, it means we’re not doing it out of necessity, but as a way of maintaining social status. So, even if our standard of living is acceptable from an absolute perspective, if it’s lower than our peer group our well-being will be diminished.

If we see people around us (family, friends and colleagues) buying more or better things than us, it makes us feel worse about our lives. Thus, how much we earn or buy in comparison to others has an impact on our well-being. That others may be up to their eyeballs in debt to acquire all these new goods barely registers. If they’ve got it, we feel that we’ve got to have it too. This is all made much worse by celebrity lifestyles which are splashed across the internet, TV and magazines, plus the advertising and brand endorsements which accompany them. The problem occurs because, unbeknownst to many of us caught up in the endless must-have-more cycle, buying more things in an effort to keep up with the Joneses will never make us feel happier. The reason? It’s what positive psychologists have dubbed the hedonic treadmill.

Barrier 4: the hedonic treadmill

The bad news – Think of the last big purchase you made, the last time you were promoted or given a pay rise. Remember how excited and happy it made you feel? Now think how long you stayed excited and happy. A few days? A week? In all likelihood, it wasn’t very long. We adapt, we get used to things, whether it’s the things we buy or other positive events and experiences in our lives. When that happens, we start taking them for granted, quickly reverting to our usual happiness baseline (also called the “set-point”). This is what happens when “the novelty wears off”.

In reality, the hedonic treadmill means that there’s little point in expecting shopping and material goods to raise your well-being permanently. They may give you a little boost of positive emotion in the short term, but the bad news is that it won’t last, and you’ll soon feel exactly as you did before. Worse still, you may feel driven to buy something else in order to make yourself feel better again. And so, it goes on. And on.

Sadly, this adaptation principle also applies to other pleasant experiences or circumstances, such as getting married. In research, the average person does not experience a lasting boost to their satisfaction after marriage. Instead, they experience a short-term increase in happiness, followed by a return to their baseline level beyond the early years.

The potential good news – On the other hand, this process of psychological adaptation also applies to unfavourable circumstances, which means that if bad things happen, we will feel worse in the short or medium term before eventually coming back up to our baseline or set-point level of happiness. However, research suggests that we adapt much more quickly to positive events and experiences than we do to negative ones.

There are two take-away messages from the hedonic treadmill story. The first is that you should expect the boost you get from positive experiences like shopping to wear off pretty quickly. The second is that over the longer term it’s worthwhile investigating other, more sustainable routes to well-being. And if you’re married or contemplating getting married, remember that it’s not a guaranteed pathway to permanent happiness – you’ll have to continually work at your relationship if you wish happiness to be your priority.

Barrier 5: lack of self-control

The fifth barrier to well-being is lack of self-control. Self-control (often called self-regulation) refers to our ability to control our impulses and channel our effort in a way that will allow us to reach particular goals. You’re not alone if you think you have low self-control – one study of the 24 character strengths of over 83,000 adults found that self-regulation scored lowest. But self-control is important; according to psychologists Mark Muraven and Roy Baumeister, lack of self-regulation is at the heart of many of the social and personal problems that we suffer in the modern, developed world.

Contrary to the popular view that happiness results from giving in to our natural desires, psychology studies show that higher well-being is actually linked to higher self-control. So, it makes perfect sense to find ways to increase your self-control. Luckily, self-control is bit like a muscle, the more you practise it, the stronger it gets. Developing self-control in one life domain can help to strengthen your self-control in other areas.

THINGS TO REMEMBER

. We naturally give negative emotions, experiences, and information more attention than positive ones.

. Negative and positive experiences of roughly the same importance do not cancel each other out – generally the negative experience will affect you more.

. Shakespeare was right – it’s true that all’s well that ends well! Try to ensure that negative events and experiences end on a high note.

. Comparing yourself upwards is likely to reduce your well-being. Comparing yourself downwards is likely to increase it.

. The novelty almost always wears off.

. Self-control is like a muscle: it improves with practice.

Standard