Category Archives: Society

Britain, Government, Legal, Military, Society

Court Martial Review Board of a Royal Marine Sergeant found guilty of murder…

THE TENETS OF JUSTICE

In the High Court, yesterday, three judges lifted the anonymity of the Royal Marine Sergeant found guilty of murdering a seriously wounded Taliban prisoner – the first British serviceman to be found guilty of murder on the battlefield since the Second World War. A fundamental and central tenet of British justice is that justice should be seen to be done.

Defence counsel argued, with reason, that both he and his family could become targets for vengeful extremists. The judges dismissed this argument.

Related:

Yet, what of another trial currently taking place of two men accused of murdering Fusilier Lee Rigby? In this case, the jury has heard the statement from one of the accused, Michael Adebolajo, who has stated how he deliberately drove a motor vehicle into the soldier at 40mph, before attempting to decapitate him with a meat cleaver.

Adebolajo believed that Fusilier Rigby was a ‘fair target’ because, he said, a soldier is ‘someone who joins the army with a kind of understanding that your life is at risk.’ According to Adebolajo, this applies even if he is a ‘random individual’ who just happened to be walking down a street at the wrong time. However, the jury has decided in his case that Adebolajo is wrong that any soldier is deemed fair game for beheading just because they ‘know the risks’.

Primarily, the law needs to balance open justice with protecting the citizen. As long as there are those who feel it is perfectly acceptable to kill people for political or religious grounds and society is aware of such people, then the law really should protect potential targets. The Royal Marine Sergeant has been sentenced by the Court Martial Review Board to a life in prison, and he is to serve a minimum of ten years. He has also been dismissed from the service with disgrace. Any thought, however, of naming the other Royal Marines involved in the case of the murdered Taliban insurgent, who have subsequently been found not guilty, should be rejected outright as speedily as possible.

It is the view of this site that the Royal Marine Sergeant should not have been named.

Standard
Britain, Economic, Government, Politics, Society

Analysis of the Autumn Statement…

AUTUMN STATEMENT

A highly charged political autumn statement delivered by the Chancellor, George Osborne, has set a trap for Labour by challenging the party to sign up to a new set of tough fiscal rules that would mean billions of pounds of new spending cuts after the 2015 general election.

Mr Osborne announced that Parliament will vote on a new ‘charter for budget responsibility’ before the election. This would set the terms of the election battle but would give maximum advantage to the Conservatives, who seem certain to pledge the running of a budget surplus once the annual deficit has been removed in 2018-19.

The Chancellor’s plans for a ‘responsible recovery for all’, however, have been dealt a blow when the independent Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) warned that house prices are expected to jump by 3.2 per cent this year, 5.2 per cent next year and 7.2 per cent in 2015. This implies that the OBR expects homes to cost 10 per cent more by 2018 than it previously predicted. Labour said that brought into question the merits of the Government’s Help to Buy scheme which guarantees 95 per cent mortgages, but which critics claim could inflate another housing bubble. Labour has warned that home-buyers would be ‘back to square one’ if prices rose sharply and they were unable to get a mortgage. But Mr Osborne said the OBR’s new forecasts still left house prices 3.1 per cent lower than their 2007 peak.

The statement contained few surprises, with the Chancellor confirming limited ‘giveaways’, including a tax break for married couples, free school meals for all five- to seven-year-olds and the scrapping of a 2p rise in fuel duty due next September.

Trumpeting higher than expected growth and lower borrowing forecasts, the Chancellor said: ‘Britain’s economic plan is working. But the job is not done. We need to secure the economy for the long term.’

Mr Osborne’s statement, seen more or less as an election gambit, creates a huge dilemma for Ed Miliband and Ed Balls, the Shadow Chancellor, who was drowned out by Tory MPs on the backbenches when he responded to it. Whilst Labour has pledged to stick to the Coalition’s day-to-day spending plans for the first year after the election the party does intend to borrow more to fund building projects such as a huge housing programme.

Charges of irresponsibility could be made by the Tories if Labour does not vote for the new charter. And whilst Labour will invariably try to find a different approach, allies of the Labour leader fear the public may stick with the Tories if Labour appears to promise more of the same austerity.

For his part, Mr Balls has vowed that Labour would not be deflected from fighting the election on the ‘cost of living’ crisis. The Shadow Chancellor said that recent statistics published showed that working people in 2015 would be £1,700 worse off on average than they were when David Cameron became Prime Minister, up from the previous estimate of £1,600. He also said that wages would fall by 5.8 per cent over the five-year term of this parliament. In its election campaign, Labour seems certain to accuse the Tories of being ‘out of touch’ and failing to understand the huge problems that ordinary people face because wages have lagged behind inflation.

The Liberal Democrats will be anxious to avoid a commitment to yet more Tory cuts. Though Nick Clegg has signed up to the idea of a new ‘fiscal framework’ which uses budget surpluses in good years to bring down debt, he seems certain to part company with the Tories by insisting that the deficit should be cleared partly by higher taxes (such as a mansion tax on homes worth more than £2m) rather than solely through spending cuts as the Tories propose.

Vince Cable, the Business Secretary’ said: ‘The Liberal Democrats are an independent party. We will go into the election with our own identity, equidistant from the other two parties and with a completely different set of policies. We will not be locked into a Tory agenda.’

Mr Osborne also set out plans to impose a cap on welfare spending. Cyclical benefits for those seeking work, part of the housing benefit budget and the basic state pension will be exempt. The move could open the door for pensioners’ perks such as winter fuel allowances, free bus travel and TV licences to be pared back.

The squeeze on public sector pay will continue, with annual rises limited to 1 per cent. But in a scheme to be trialled, some government organisations will be given the freedom to make the trade-off between pay and jobs.

AUTUMN STATEMENT – MAIN POINTS:

Pensions – People in their 40s get state pension at 68. People in 30s at 69

Growth – 2013: 1.4% (up from 0.6%); 2014: 2.4%

Cuts – Extra £1bn from government departments each year until 2017

Borrowing – 2014-15: £96bn, 2015-16: £79bn, 2018-19: £2bn surplus

 

Economic growth – Growth forecast for this year increased from 0.6% to 1.4%, revised up for next year from 1.8% to 2.4%, but then down slightly for the following three years to 2.2%, 2.6%, and 2.7%.

Revised figures from the Office for National Statistics show that UK GDP declined by 7.2% in 2008-09, not 6.3% as previously thought, equivalent in value to £112bn.

Government Borrowing – The UK’s “underlying” deficit – a measure that excludes the acquisition of the Royal Mail pension scheme and the effects of quantitative easing – has been revised down by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) to 6.8% this year, and to 5.6% next year.

It is then expected to fall to 4.4%, 2.7% and 1.2% in the subsequent financial years.

The OBR predicts there will be a small cash surplus in 2018-19.

Borrowing is expected to come in at £111bn for this year, falling in 2014-15 to £96bn, then down to £79bn in 2015-16, £51bn the year after and £23bn the year after that.

Public debt this year is due to total 75.5% of GDP – £18bn lower than forecast in March – rising to 78.3% next year, before peaking at 80% the next year. By 2017-18, debt is expected to be more than £80bn lower than forecast in March.

Departmental budgets will be cut by about £1bn next year and the year after.

Benefits and Pensions – The state pension age is to increase to 68 in the mid-2030s and to 69 in the late 2040s. In April 2014, the state pension will rise by £2.95 a week.

Overall welfare spending is to be capped.

Anyone aged 18 to 21 claiming benefits without basic English or Maths will be required to undertake training from day one or lose their entitlement. People unemployed for more than six months to be forced to start a traineeship, take work experience or do a community work placement or lose benefits.

Taxes and Allowances – From April 2015, capital gains tax will be imposed on future gains made by non-residents who sell residential property in the UK.

From 1 January 2014, the rate of the bank levy will rise to 0.156%, and is estimated to raise £2.7bn in 2014-15 and £2.9bn each year from 2015-16.

Employer National Insurance contributions are to be scrapped on 1.5 million jobs for young people.

Stamp duty on shares purchased in exchange traded funds is to be abolished.

The personal income tax allowance will rise to £10,000 from April 2014, and then increase from 2015-16 by the Consumer Prices Index (CPI) measure of inflation.

A married couples and civil partners tax break, which is set to cost about £700m a year, is proposed to start in April 2015, enabling people to transfer £1,000 of their income tax allowance to their partners.

Business rates in England to be capped at 2% rather than linked to RPI inflation, with some retail premises in England to get a discount. Businesses moving into vacant high-street properties will have their rates cut by 50%.

From April, a new tax relief is to be introduced for investment in social enterprises and new social impact bonds.

Jobs and Training – The number of people claiming unemployment benefits is down 200,000, with unemployment now forecast to fall from 7.6% this year to 7% in 2015. Unemployment is then expected to fall further to 5.6% by 2018.

Total number of jobs to rise by 400,000 this year and 3.1 million jobs predicted to be created by 2019.

A boost in the government’s start-up loans scheme will aim to help 50,000 more people start their own businesses.

Export finance capacity available to support British businesses will be doubled to £50bn.

Transport – Petrol taxes stay frozen – a planned rise of 2p per litre for next year is to be scrapped.

Regulated train fares will rise in line with inflation, not at 1% above RPI as planned.

The tax disc to show motorists have paid vehicle excise duty is to be replaced with an electronic system.

Education and Families – An extra 30,000 places at English universities will be created in 2014-15. The following year, the current cap on student numbers will be abolished entirely.

Science, technology and engineering courses will receive increased funding, and a new science centre in Edinburgh University is to be named after Prof Peter Higgs, the discoverer of the Higgs boson particle.

The proportion of young people from disadvantaged backgrounds applying to university is up.

An additional 20,000 apprenticeships are to be funded over the next two years.

All pupils at state schools in England in Reception, Year 1 and Year 2 are to get free school lunches from next September, at an estimated cost of £600m a year.

Housing – The government hopes £1bn in loans will boost housing developments in Manchester and Leeds, among other sites.

The housing revenue account’s borrowing limit is to rise by £300m.

Councils are to sell off the most expensive social housing and rundown urban housing estates to be regenerated, and workers who live in council houses are to be given priority on housing lists if they need to move home to find a job.

Infrastructure – Tax allowances aiming to encourage investment in shale gas to cut tax on early profits by 50%.

More investment in “quantum technology”, which involves attempting to apply the strange behaviour of materials on a tiny scale to practical purposes, is promised.

Overseas Aid – The government’s pledge to spend 0.7% of gross national income on international development is to be met without an increase to the current aid budget.

Standard
Britain, Economic, Energy, European Union, Government, Politics, Society

Reduction in energy bills following the removal of green levies – a step in the right direction…

ENERGY BILLS

Householders will be somewhat relieved to hear that the UK government will be pegging back the recent increases made to electricity prices by all the major suppliers. The reduction is being made because the government is removing some of the green levies applied to bills to pay for policies designed to either reduce energy use or to encourage renewable energy development. These levies can be as much as 11 per cent that are directly added on to domestic bills. The impact of green levies on suppliers is to be lessened and the savings passed on to consumers. Utility bills will still go up by an average of around £70, rather than £123, a saving of about £50 this winter.

Changes are being made to two of these levies, the Energy Company Obligation, which commits energy firms under statute to assist with the costs and installation of better insulation, and the Warm Home Discount, which reduces bills for elderly consumers over 75. The idea is to transfer some of the money raised to pay from these schemes to general taxation so the taxpayer rather than the energy consumer foots the bill.

These charges are not being scrapped, but diverted. According to Ed Davey, the Energy Secretary, this will cost the taxpayer somewhere in the region of £600 million. The problem, however, goes much further than the bills themselves. Whilst Labour have proposed a freeze or cap on bills from 2015, this is wholly unrealistic since energy companies cannot control wholesale costs and will be required to invest for the future. The dilemma of market failure arising, something which is still to be investigated, will be attributable to Labour – because when the party took office in 1997, there were 17 companies in the energy sector that kept the market competitive. By the time Labour left office in 2010, there were just six remaining. Most analysts now perceive the energy market as operating like a cartel where energy prices are effectively rigged.

All the main political parties must share some responsibility for the confusing mess that passes for an energy policy. They are now engaged in a political battle over who can promise the lowest prices. Yet, the biggest problem concerns energy security.

Next winter looks certain to be affected by a coalescence of factors that will alter the capacity of the electricity system. A recently published report from the Royal Academy of Engineering suggests that the mothballing of gas-fired power plants and decarbonisation targets could lead to a ‘significant reduction in the resilience of the system’.

Undoubtedly, the cheapest way to generate electricity at the moment is by burning coal. The global price of coal has dropped substantially in recent months as coal mines in many parts of the world, including America, remain under-exploited. Yet, amendments to the UK Energy Bill are expected to force coal stations to close earlier than planned. In addition, there are also doubts in the medium term over the nuclear power programme planned at Hinkley Point, with questions in Brussels over the payments of subsidies to French and Chinese companies. Future supply, then, is the critical issue: energy consumers may be pleased to see their bills go up less than originally planned, even though many will still be paying for it through taxation. But they will be appalled if the lights go out. And for those who believe that green energy is greatly over-valued will complain that the government is just shifting the burden from one set of people to another.

The finer details of the changes also reveal that homebuyers will become eligible for a £1,000 contribution towards insulating their new home. Mr Davey has said this will be paid via a reduction in the stamp duty paid on the purchase price.

The changes to energy bills might just cause the energy companies and the government to be more transparent about exactly what makes up the unit price of gas and electricity on our bills. Hopefully, that might lead to them being more sensitive to that information, delivering consumers a far better deal in the longer term.

Standard