Arts, Books, History

Book Review: In Rome’s Long Shadow

LITERARY REVIEW

Intro: Ancient Rome offers many valuable lessons about how to safeguard democracy. History shows us there is only one way to avoid tyranny – and that’s through free speech

We all know of the adage “history repeats itself”. And historians have been repeating that cliché ever since Classical times.

For Roman historians like Livy, history was full of brief anecdotes and illustrations, showing what true tyranny looks like, how freedom is won, and what it takes to sustain a decent political system.

History should never be seen as a dry chronicle of dates and events: we should learn from it about human heroism and triumph, as well as idiocy and wickedness, and then practice and exercise the good from what we’ve learned.

This is the central theme at the heart of this book by Jamie Gianoutsos, an intellectually demanding but fascinating overview of how Rome faced the same problems as we do, dealt with them (or failed to), and inspired later rulers, from the Italian Renaissance to America’s Founding Fathers.

The latter were so obsessed with Rome they created Senators and diplomatic Consuls. Even now, Washington’s political centre brims with “Corinthian columns and toga-styled statues”.

Key themes

Eschewing straight narrative, the book examines key themes: liberty and slavery, women and the republic, tyranny and lust.

The Roman republic was born out of a horrific rape, and they never forgot it. The last tyrant-king was Tarquinius Superbus, whose son committed this vile and horrific crime against the virtuous Lucretia, another man’s wife.

Before stabbing herself to death, Lucretia cried out for vengeance, whereupon her cousin verbally snapped at her mourners to “Trade your tears for marching. Act like men!”. Very Roman.

The corrupt last kings of Rome were duly chased from the city, and Rome became a proud republic – until Augustus, and the return of the emperors.

For the freedom-loving Romans of the old republic then, those who lorded it over the people without their consent were symbolically described as rapists. That’s an extraordinary and disturbing image, but one that inspired the American republicans fighting British rule in the 18th century.

They castigated Britain for ravishing the innocent land of America, and when opposing one of Britain’s Coercive Acts, in 1774, a shocking cartoon was published showing prime minister Lord North forcibly pouring the hated and heavily-taxed British tea down the throat of a Native American girl. It was ferocious political propaganda – and it worked.

The Romans saw there were three forms of government, all of which have a dark shadow: monarchy, which can denigrate into tyranny; aristocracy, literally “rule by the best,” which can become a corrupt self-serving elite or oligarchy; and democracy, which can become mob rule by an ignorant, bullying majority. In fact, some like the historian Tacitus, believed that all three are bound to deteriorate into their shadow versions.

Democracries always turn self-indulgent until the Strong Man rises to impose law and order, and the cycle begins again.

Roman historian Livy warned about certain societies which appear to be “in love with death both individual and collective”, and are doomed to be replaced.

There’s a riveting chapter on the connection between democracy and free speech: one cannot exist without the other.

After the rise of the emperors, books were burned and writers like poor old Ovid, the poet, were exiled to the Black Sea coast.

Under the austere but freedom-loving old Roman republic, freedom of speech was protected to the hilt: all speech, without qualification. There was no State police force, the author reminds us, nor censors. Even plain invective and abuse were fine: Cicero once called an opponent in a law court a “bastard”. No one objected. Deeds might be illegal, but mere words never could be.

This example inspired the republicans of 17th-century England, like the poet John Milton, who insisted that “for the truth to be reached, all opinions must be voiced freely”.

It also gave rise to the first recognisable newspapers, but not without insult as they were denigrated as “this moth-eating crew of newsmongers” – perhaps the first (but not the last) rant slung at those wretched journalists. But newspapers became essential in informing the people.

False facts

Over in America a century later, Founding Fathers Thomas Jefferson and James Madison privately discussed “private facts” – what we would now call fake news or misinformation. In the name of freedom, they defended the right to publish even these.

In 1798, the States passed a Sedition Act, which condemned anyone who dared “write, print, utter or publish . . . any false, scandalous and malicious writings against the government”. Jefferson was horrified, and the Act expired in 1801. Falsehoods and malice were seen as the price you paid for freedom.

In Rome’s Long Shadow the narrative shows how today’s troublesome issues were long-since debated, though not solved, by some of the most influential historical figures.

– In Rome’s Long Shadow by Jamie Gianoutos, is published by Allen Lane, 384pp

Standard
Britain, Government, Politics, Society

Disaffection is threatening our free and stable society

BRITAIN

FOR WHOM really was the winner in last week’s by-elections? “None of The Above” Party seems a more appropriate declaration given that 60 per cent of the electorate did not bother to exercise a right to vote in either of the seats being contested for. That’s a democratic crying shame. We elect our MPs about a dozen times during our adult lives.

Some will not try to diminish the Tory failure, but it was considerable. Nor should we assume that Labour is too weakly supported that it cannot win a General Election, for it is not. Or that the Reform Party is not a major threat to Rishi Sunak, because it is. Disaffected Tories are moving in their droves to Reform, unsettling for the Conservative Party if they have ambitions of holding on to power. More than ten per cent of Conservatives have already migrated. Yet, these simple truths are mere squalls on the surface of British politics.

Troubled depths lie beneath, which are full of potential dangers for our stable and free society.

Politics in the UK has fractured over the past quarter of a century. Until the eras of Thatcher and Blair, this country was still divided politically on much the same lines that had divided it in 1950. One big party stood for the industrial working class, the inhabitants of council estates and 19th Century terraces, and also for a small layer of city-dwelling radical intellectuals. The other stood for tree-lined suburbs and the countryside, white-collar workers, for small businessmen and professionals.

But by the time Mrs Thatcher had finished, and Mr Blair had begun his swinging social revolution, we were a different country.

All the old frontiers had melted away, just as the Iron Curtain bulldozed down made headway for a new Europe. Vast new problems grew and overshadowed the old ones: the replacement of industrial jobs with high-tech work or with call-centre drudgery, the flood of women into the workforce and away from the home, the astonishing expansion of universities, the transformation of family life, the computer revolution, and, perhaps above all, large-scale immigration.

Loyalties shifted and blurred, as the Brexit referendum showed beyond doubt. Politics had become troubling and deeply divisive.

In spite of that, Tory and Labour politicians still sought to win votes by using the old spells and incantations, which no longer worked – more police officers on the beat on one side, ever-expanding promises to fix the NHS on the other. The wider public, unfooled, look on with increasing dismay.

How is it so many pledges and promises are never fulfilled? Why is a rich country, full of skills and talent, now so lacking in good government that we navigate our lives amid a maze of potholes and crumbling roads, unprotected by an absent police force, and the many who are stuck in queues for everything from a dental appointment to hospital admission for a medical procedure or major operation? Public angst is growing.

We should not, however, despise our politicians; of whatever affiliation they may be. We live in an ancient and free democracy, and it should be allowed to thrive. Most people will understand that politicians bear a heavy responsibility and in many cases are personally devoted to serving their constituents. The great majority of parliamentarians are honest and well-intentioned.

But something has gone badly amiss in their relationship with those they represent. If left uncorrected, and the widespread discontent and disengagement now rife among us are not assuaged, a portal will open through which dangerous extremists can enter mainstream politics.

Such extremism is personified in the worrying figure of George Galloway, who appears now to have a real chance in the chaotic Rochdale by-election. As a lone maverick, Mr Galloway can do little harm. But what if other, similar figures, begin to profit from discontent and disaffection? A gateway certainly exists for trumping exploitation.

Our mainstream politicians should stop trying to placate voters with mere slogans and instead recognise that their concerns are real and pressing. The whole point of democracy is that such discontents be addressed.

Standard
Arts, Culture, Human Rights, Politics, Society

Book banning in the US is inspiring educational censorship elsewhere

CENSORSHIP

BOOK BANNING is spreading at an alarming rate in school districts across the United States. PEN America recently documented more than 2,500 books that have been banned stemming across 32 different states during the 2021-22 academic year.

These bans are not isolated incidents, but part of a coordinated assault on public education that’s taking aim at the teaching of race, gender, LGBTQ+ identities and US history.

Demands to ban books in American schools is not new. But book banning now has erupted into a national movement. Coordinated and highly organised activist groups have transformed school board meetings into political battlegrounds, threatening educators and undermining the freedom to learn.

These efforts to censor books are an affront to the core principles of free expression and open inquiry that US democracy swears by. Equally worrying, however, is the fact that these patterns of attacks on public education in the US appears to be inspiring similar efforts in other countries, even though such censorship campaigns haven’t had as much success there yet.

In the UK, officials are raising the spectre of critical race theory in schools – an issue that was not previously a topic of debate or concern – to try and stop the teaching of histories that explore systemic racism. That’s part of what authors have described as a mood ‘shift’ in the UK – a budding ‘culture war’ that is leading to the censorship and removal of books from school shelves. Books being removed are often children’s books that look at institutional racism, diversity and LGBTQ+ identities.

Echoes of US-based group tactics are also manifesting in Canada, with parental groups asking school boards to ban certain books – again with LGBTQ+ content – and seeking to change curricular topics that they see as being part of the teaching of critical race theory.

The book banning movement has also gained the attention of politicians. Australia’s Senate voted against the inclusion of critical race theory in the country’s school curriculum in 2021.

Of course, educational censorship laws and book bans, particularly aimed at silencing certain peoples, religions, or viewpoints, are tactics that have long been used by governments.

Click on page 2 to continue reading

Standard