Arts, Books, History

Book Review: In Rome’s Long Shadow

LITERARY REVIEW

Intro: Ancient Rome offers many valuable lessons about how to safeguard democracy. History shows us there is only one way to avoid tyranny – and that’s through free speech

We all know of the adage “history repeats itself”. And historians have been repeating that cliché ever since Classical times.

For Roman historians like Livy, history was full of brief anecdotes and illustrations, showing what true tyranny looks like, how freedom is won, and what it takes to sustain a decent political system.

History should never be seen as a dry chronicle of dates and events: we should learn from it about human heroism and triumph, as well as idiocy and wickedness, and then practice and exercise the good from what we’ve learned.

This is the central theme at the heart of this book by Jamie Gianoutsos, an intellectually demanding but fascinating overview of how Rome faced the same problems as we do, dealt with them (or failed to), and inspired later rulers, from the Italian Renaissance to America’s Founding Fathers.

The latter were so obsessed with Rome they created Senators and diplomatic Consuls. Even now, Washington’s political centre brims with “Corinthian columns and toga-styled statues”.

Key themes

Eschewing straight narrative, the book examines key themes: liberty and slavery, women and the republic, tyranny and lust.

The Roman republic was born out of a horrific rape, and they never forgot it. The last tyrant-king was Tarquinius Superbus, whose son committed this vile and horrific crime against the virtuous Lucretia, another man’s wife.

Before stabbing herself to death, Lucretia cried out for vengeance, whereupon her cousin verbally snapped at her mourners to “Trade your tears for marching. Act like men!”. Very Roman.

The corrupt last kings of Rome were duly chased from the city, and Rome became a proud republic – until Augustus, and the return of the emperors.

For the freedom-loving Romans of the old republic then, those who lorded it over the people without their consent were symbolically described as rapists. That’s an extraordinary and disturbing image, but one that inspired the American republicans fighting British rule in the 18th century.

They castigated Britain for ravishing the innocent land of America, and when opposing one of Britain’s Coercive Acts, in 1774, a shocking cartoon was published showing prime minister Lord North forcibly pouring the hated and heavily-taxed British tea down the throat of a Native American girl. It was ferocious political propaganda – and it worked.

The Romans saw there were three forms of government, all of which have a dark shadow: monarchy, which can denigrate into tyranny; aristocracy, literally “rule by the best,” which can become a corrupt self-serving elite or oligarchy; and democracy, which can become mob rule by an ignorant, bullying majority. In fact, some like the historian Tacitus, believed that all three are bound to deteriorate into their shadow versions.

Democracries always turn self-indulgent until the Strong Man rises to impose law and order, and the cycle begins again.

Roman historian Livy warned about certain societies which appear to be “in love with death both individual and collective”, and are doomed to be replaced.

There’s a riveting chapter on the connection between democracy and free speech: one cannot exist without the other.

After the rise of the emperors, books were burned and writers like poor old Ovid, the poet, were exiled to the Black Sea coast.

Under the austere but freedom-loving old Roman republic, freedom of speech was protected to the hilt: all speech, without qualification. There was no State police force, the author reminds us, nor censors. Even plain invective and abuse were fine: Cicero once called an opponent in a law court a “bastard”. No one objected. Deeds might be illegal, but mere words never could be.

This example inspired the republicans of 17th-century England, like the poet John Milton, who insisted that “for the truth to be reached, all opinions must be voiced freely”.

It also gave rise to the first recognisable newspapers, but not without insult as they were denigrated as “this moth-eating crew of newsmongers” – perhaps the first (but not the last) rant slung at those wretched journalists. But newspapers became essential in informing the people.

False facts

Over in America a century later, Founding Fathers Thomas Jefferson and James Madison privately discussed “private facts” – what we would now call fake news or misinformation. In the name of freedom, they defended the right to publish even these.

In 1798, the States passed a Sedition Act, which condemned anyone who dared “write, print, utter or publish . . . any false, scandalous and malicious writings against the government”. Jefferson was horrified, and the Act expired in 1801. Falsehoods and malice were seen as the price you paid for freedom.

In Rome’s Long Shadow the narrative shows how today’s troublesome issues were long-since debated, though not solved, by some of the most influential historical figures.

– In Rome’s Long Shadow by Jamie Gianoutos, is published by Allen Lane, 384pp

Standard
Britain, Culture, Government, Society, Technology

Whose job is it to keep us nice online?

SOCIETAL: SOCIAL MEDIA

Imagine and visualise a debate that you’ve just had on stage at the Cheltenham Literature Festival concerning a neat little modern conundrum: ‘Is social media the curse of our age?’ Imagine, too, that you and your fellow panellists have agreed that it probably is. In this scenario, should you, or should you not, tweet about it?

We would assume that people normally would. But maybe you would be unsure. What would be your motivation? Would you be publishing an event that you’d found fascinating? Quite likely. Or would you just be craving the sort of “like”-induced serotonin surge you and your fellow panellists had just been talking about, given your addiction to social media networking? What demons were ruling you? What damn tech tricks made you feel that you ought?

And so it goes viral after comments from the Festival audience stick with you. The young woman who saw social media as the vector of the eating disorder she suffered from as a teenager, but who now was using social media platforms to rebuild her sense of self-worth. The older man who, after tweeting in support of Boris Johnson’s comments on burkas, had been shocked to find himself subject to an onslaught of fury, including people trying to get him sacked. Or, another man, say, active on platforms but tired of competing with screens for attention and convinced that the world around him was narcissistic and utterly crazy.

There might be a sense of social media acting the heavy beast squatting upon all our shoulders, forever seen in the corner of an eye. It might also be an overdue reminder that your own thoughts about all this can get a little lofty. Yet, we could trot out the gotcha about the billionaire moguls who run these platforms banning their own children from using them, even while marketing them to yours. We could talk for hours about the damage being done to the fabric of our democracy.

For most people, however, concern about social media has nothing to do with any of that. Instead it is about obsession and compulsion. It is about self-worth and self-harm. It is about friends and relatives developing new violent politics that seem to have come from nowhere. It is about teenagers living their lives as a constant performance on apps that their parents barely comprehend, for audiences that they can scarcely imagine. It sits in the lives of many as an ever-grinding mill of misery, even when they cannot imagine life without it, and they feel that something must be done.

 

EARLIER this year the Government let it be known that it was working on a white paper of proposals to tackle the nebulous business of online harm. Matt Hancock, then culture secretary, declared that Britain was to become “the safest place in the world” to be online. You’ll maybe understand the urge of ministers and can probably see where this is going: “something must be done”. But does this rule out making anyone less fearful?

In some areas, certainly, legislation is desirable and overdue. Criminal hate speech, libel, grooming, copyright violation, fraud and violent radicalisation are all areas that technology companies should be taking far more seriously. We really should have no objection to them being forced to do so. Likewise, there is growing evidence that the chemical hits of serotonin, dopamine and adrenaline that drive online behaviour creates a dependency culture, in the manner of nicotine or cocaine. The notion of a cigarette packed-style warning on your Snapchat or WhatsApp might seem ludicrous today but it could become a necessary measure to help improve physical and mental wellbeing.

The pervasive public miseries of social media, though, are more low level. They involve not hate speech but vitriol and nastiness; not extremism but political polarisation; not libel but rudeness and disrespect. Not grooming, even, but sexualisation. They involve, in other words, forms of speech that today are free and uninhibited, and where the government almost certainly plans to make less free.

Who will complain? Feel the way the wind blows. The public sees a harm and worries about it. Paradoxically the users of social media are increasingly censorious, blocking undesirables and avoiding certain platforms. In parliament, the very bedrock of democracy, you have a cohort of MPs radicalised against popular free speech by some 100 tweets a day threatening rape or murder, or by calling them traitors or fascists.

Many will wish that social media giants should be policing themselves more effectively, yet simultaneously doubt they ever will. Tell those same people that the state ought to do it instead and they will balk, hard. You will remember the instinctive illiberalism of so many politicians in the Leveson battles over press regulation. You might be feeling it is coming back.

Next time, when it’s those hated tech behemoths who pilfer the revenues from traditional media organisations, will even the press be prepared to put up a fight? They must. Like it or not, what was true with the press is even more true for social media. Except in areas of outright criminality, liberal democracies do not curb your freedom of expression. They may fret about it, lambast it, implore others to close their ears. Yet the moment they shut it down they are liberal no more.

This fight is coming. It is likely to be ugly and all the nicest people will be on the wrong side. Trolls, those ugly creatures who once lived under bridges, now reside right behind the screen you’re looking at. Prowl they will. But you have a choice.

Standard